JOURNAL ARTICLE EVALUATION
 
Structure
What is the intention of the study? How does the author outline the intention early on; and how is this carried through the paper? What theory was used (if any)?
 
Awareness of Current Debate
What existing debate in the field is the study addressing? Specify clearly by undertaking a Literature Review of academic journal articles using the online library resources (at least 10 cited articles).
 
Implications for Managers
What are the implication to the task of managing an organization, a company or an institution? Do you agree with the articles propositions? Why or why not  based on your experience in managing people and organizations?
 
Originality
What is the unique and valuable contribution of the study to the body of knowledge? What are the management applications of the findings? What areas of further research does it suggest?
 
Clarity and Readability
Assess the adequacy of attention on grammar, sentence structure, and explanation of jargon or acronyms.
 


期刊文章评价
 
结构体
研究的目的是什么？ 作者如何在早期就概述意图？ 这篇论文如何进行？ 使用了什么理论（如果有）？
 
当前辩论的意识
该研究解决了该领域中现有的哪些争论？ 通过使用在线图书馆资源（至少10篇被引用的文章）对学术期刊文章进行文献综述，从而明确说明。
 
对经理的启示
管理组织，公司或机构的任务有什么含义？ 您是否同意文章的主张？基于您在管理人员和组织方面的经验，同意或者不同意，为什么？
 
独创性
研究对知识体系的独特而宝贵的贡献是什么？ 结果的管理应用是什么？ 它建议进一步研究哪些领域？
 
清晰度和可读性
评估对语法，句子结构以及术语或首字母缩写词的注意是否足够。